Open Letter: EDRi warns of EU’s undemocratic attempt to introduce surveillance in satellite-based communications

The European Parliament and the Council of the European Union are currently negotiating two laws to regulate communications service providers, including satellite-based ones. In both laws, the Commission has sneakily attempted to attribute itself the possibility to impose intrusive surveillance, notably data retention and interception obligations, on those satellite operators through opaque procedures. EDRi and its members warns against these unchecked powers and asks the Parliament and the Council to stand for fundamental rights and the EU’s principles for good law-making.

By EDRi · November 17, 2026

EDRi and members concerned about attempt to introduce unlawful data retention obligations

EDRi and its members are writing to the European Parliament and the Council of the European Union to express their serious concerns about the attempt to introduce unlawful data retention obligations through EU authorisation procedures for satellite operators under the Digital Networks Act (DNA) and Mobile Satellite Services (MSS) Regulation proposals.

In short, the Commission could impose data retention and interception obligations on satellite operators and define their modalities through a comitology procedure, which is shrouded in secrecy. The discretionary powers granted to the Commission are therefore far-reaching, bypass essential EU democratic processes, and may have grave implications for the rights to privacy and data protection.

The introduction of data retention obligations in the DNA and the MSS are also wholly inappropriate as the Commission is currently assessing the impacts of data retention as part of a wider process to determine the need for a new EU framework or not. Furthermore, it is settled case-law by the Court of Justice of the European Union that the general and indiscriminate retention of traffic and location data is a serious interference with fundamental rights, and is incompatible with EU law as a preventive measure for combatting crime.