Participate in the Public Consultation on the European Commission’s KIDS Act Proposal
The European Commission recently published a proposal for a Regulation aiming to ensure greater safety for young people online, called the KIDS Act. It then opened a public consultation for everyone to speak up about their support or concerns – and oh do we have some!
The European Commission recently published a proposal for a Regulation aiming to ensure greater safety for young people online, called the KIDS Act. It then opened a public consultation for everyone to speak up about their support or concerns – and oh do we have some!
While EDRi is still in the process of finalising its position and recommendations for this file, there are certain elements which are very clear already. We invite all readers of the EDRi-gram to submit a short opinion to the consultation, open until 3 December at midnight, covering at least the following points:
- Criticising the widespread and mandatory use of age verification: because of it, everybody becomes suspected of being a child until proven innocent; many people will not be willing or able to prove they are of the right age (because they lack IT equipment, ID documents, digital literacy, or trust) and will therefore be unfairly restricted in their exercise of fundamental rights online.
- Arguing that social media bans should come as last resort: if they are deployed at all, the age verification-powered ban should only be applied if the provider of the service can demonstrate that it hasn’t managed to mitigate the risks facing young people. In such cases, bans should be limited to the relevant part of the service, instead of covering it in whole.
- Arguing that every protection granted to young people should also be offered to adults: no one, whether they are 15, 18 or 88 years old, wants or deserves services designed to lead to “excessive or compulsive use” (article 9), recommender systems optimisation which exploit the user’s vulnerability (article 10(2)), or which determines what is best for the user through tracking-based “implicit engagement-based signals” (a.k.a. tracking).
- Underlining that young people have the right to be online and exercise their freedoms, and that the proposal goes against the United Nations General Comment No. 25 (2021) on children’s rights in relation to the digital environment. This is particularly important in today’s context, where thousands of young people of all ages use social media in the context of protests to inform, express and mobilise themselves, and to document police violence.
- Criticising the proof of parental authority as too extreme (article 26), and criticising the power that guardians have over the child account as overly intrusive (pre-approving contacts, article 6(2); overseeing the content viewed by the child, article 7(4)(d)).
