On 15 May 2019, Facebook’s Head of Public Policy for the Netherlands spoke at a round table in the House of Representatives about data and democracy. The Facebook employee reassured members of parliament that Facebook has implemented measures to prevent election manipulation. He stated: “You can now only advertise political messages in a country, if you’re a resident of that country.” Nothing seems to be further from the truth.
Dutch EDRi member Bits of Freedom wanted to know if it were possible to target Dutch voters from a foreign country, using the type of post and method of advertising that were employed in, among others, the “Leave” campaign in the UK. From Germany, they logged in to a German Facebook account, created a new page, and uploaded a well-known Dutch political meme. They then paid to have it shown to Dutch voters and settled the bill using a German bank account. Contrary to what Facebook led members of parliament to believe, there was nothing that stood in their way of doing so.
The other way around was just as easy. Facebook failed to stop Bits of Freedom from targeting German voters interested in German political parties Christian Democratic Union of Germany (CDU) and Alternative for Germany (AfD) with a CDU/AfD meme, even though they were using a Dutch Facebook account, had signed in from the Netherlands, and payed for the ad with a Dutch bank account. Better yet, Facebook suggested to add to their demographic, people with the additional interests “nationalism” and “military”. Thanks, Facebook!
We’re not dealing with a company that occasionally messes up. Facebook has time and time again exhibited a complete disregard for our democracy, freedom of expression, and privacy. Therefore, Bits of Freedom called on the House of Representatives to take action. On 20 May, on the Dutch current affairs television program “Nieuwsuur”, Labour Party (PvdA) leader Lodewijk Asscher responded: “Facebook promises to do better, and time and time again their promises prove worthless. Facebook says all the right things but in reality is a threat to democracy.” Liberal MP Kees Verhoeven (D66) added: “As far as I’m concerned, now is the time we stop relying on self-regulation and trusting companies’ promises, and start regulating.”
This article was first published at https://www.bitsoffreedom.nl/2019/05/21/facebook-lies-to-dutch-parliament-about-election-manipulation/
Bits of Freedom
Nieuwsuur: Facebook lies about political advertising (20.05.2019)
Bits of Freedom
Nieuwsuur: Facebook lies about political advertising (only in Dutch, 20.05.2019)
Steps you can take to minimise the political ads you see online (19.05.2019)
(Contribution by Evelyn Austin, EDRi member Bits of Freedom, the Netherlands)