Copyright reform: Document pool
The current European copyright system is broken. We need to repair it as soon as possible, in a way that respects the rights and values of European citizens and creators – not only those of intermediaries such as publishers, record companies or collecting societies!
The European Commission has set in its agenda reforming copyright as one of the foundations to build the Digital Single Market. We welcome the attempt to do so because EU’s copyright legislation is outdated. However, given the dangerous threats which are present in the proposal launched by the European Commission (see here), we will need to monitor the developments of the proposal very closely.
In this document pool we will be adding all the relevant documents on the EU copyright reform that will be published or leaked. This will allow you to follow the developments of this crucial file for EU citizens’ rights to access to culture, and to their freedom of expression. It will also serve as a reference throughout the process.
EDRi’s analysis and recommendations
Legislative documents
EDRi’s blogposts and press releases
Other
Key policy-makers
Key dates
EDRi’s analysis and recommendations
- EDRi’s booklet on Copyright (2013).
- EDRi’s response to the 2014 public consultation on the planned reform (2014).
- EDRi’s Copyfails series – and suggestions how to fix copyright (2016).
- The Copyright Reform: a guide for the perplexed, prepared with Communia. Analysis on the main aspects of the proposal (2016).
- EDRi’s response to the public consultation on the role of publishers in the copyright value chain and on the ‘panorama exception’ (15.06.2016)
- Deconstructing the Article 13 of the Copyright proposal of the European Commission, revision 2 (2017)
- Re-Deconstructing the Article 13 of the Copyright proposal text as adopted by the JURI Committee (26.06.2018)
- Twitter thread with all the organisations and individuals opposing Article 13. (16.06.2018)
- Twitter thread explaining Article 13. (15.06.2018)
Legislative documents
- Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on copyright in the Digital Single Market (14.09.2016)
- European Parliament’s position:
- Procedure file: Copyright in the digital single market
- FINAL Official text to be voted on 26.03.2019 [PDF]
- Additional AMs (26.03.2019):
- AMs 262-268 (S&D Group – Deletion of Article 13 (+ Recitals) | EFDD Group: Proposal for rejection of EC proposal and Amendments to Delete Articles 11 & 13)
- AMs 269-270 (+38 MEPs driven by MEP Reda: Deletion of Articles 11 & 13)
- AM 272 (MEP Axel Voss with regards to sports event’s organisers issues)
- Additional AMs (26.03.2019):
- Committee Opinions:
- JURI Draft Report (17.03.2017)
- Amendments 73 – 272 [PDF, DOC]
- Amendments 273 – 472 [PDF, DOC]
- Amendments 473 – 672 [PDF, DOC]
- Amendments 673 – 872 [PDF, DOC]
- Amendments 873 – 996 [PDF, DOC]
- Results of the vote in the JURI Committee on 20.06.2018 [PDF]
- Report as adopted by the JURI Committee (29.06.2018) PDF – DOC
- Erratum for Aricle 11 on the Report as adopted by JURI (29.06.2018) PDF – DOC.
- Results of the roll-call votes on 05.07.2018 that rejected the mandate for trilogues [PDF].
- All amendments for the 12.09.2018 vote in Plenary
- Voting list for the 12.09.2018 vote in Plenary
- Roll-call votes of the Plenary vote on 12.09.2018
- Provisional adopted text adopted in the Plenary vote on 12.09.2018.
- Consolidated text of the trilogue agreements (19.02.2019)
- Leaked JURI Draft Report (leak 08.03.2017) and explanatory statement (leak 08.03.2017)
- CULT Committee Opinion (
11.07.2017Updated version from 04.09.2017) - IMCO Committee Opinion (14.06.2017)
ITRE Committee Opinion (01.08.2017)- LIBE Committee Opinion (22.11.2017)
- Update! Final published text of the Copyright Directive (17.05.2018) [pdf]
- JURI Draft Report (17.03.2017)
- Council of the EU texts
- Final Agreement after the trilogue negotiations (16.02.2019)
- Presidency compromise proposal (consolidated version) and state of play (13.12.2017)
- Orientation debate on Articles 11 and 13 (16.01.2018)
- Bulgarian Council Presidency’s discussion paper [PDF] (06.02.2018)
- Bulgarian Council Presidency’s compromise proposal on Articles 2 and 13 [PDF] (02.03.2018)
- Consolidated Presidency Proposal [PDF] (23.03.2018)
- Presidency questions related to Articles 3a, 11, 13 [PDF] (12.04.2018)
- Leaked proposal for amendments from ES, FR, PT and IT to the Presidency compromise (8145/18) (02.05.18) [PDF]
- Compromise text from the Bulgarian Presidency with a mandate for negotiations [PDF] (17.05.2018)
- German non-paper on Art 13 (08.01.2019) [PDF]
- Romanian Presidency Compromise Proposal WK 421/2019 (13.01.2018) [PDF]
- Romanian Presidency: Update of negotiating mandate (17.01.20148) [PDF]
EDRi’s blogposts and press releases
- Letter to the EU Council: Stand for citizen’s rights and the European digital economy in the copyright negotiations! (20.11.2018)
- Press Release: EU Parliament flip-flops backwards on copyright (12.09.2018)
- Deconstructing an MEP’s support for the Copyright Directive (11.09.2018)
- Copyright: Compulsory filtering instead of obligatory filtering – a compromise? (04.09.2018)
- The EU gets another opportunity to improve copyright rules (25.07.2018)
- EP Plenary on the Copyright Directive – Who voted what? (23.07.2018)
- Press Release: EU Parliamentarians support an open, democratic debate on Copyright Directive (05.07.2018)
- How the EU copyright proposal will hurt the web and Wikipedia (02.07.2018)
- Re-Deconstructing upload filters proposal in the copyright Directive (28.06.2018)
- Moving Parliament’s copyright discussions into the public domain (27.06.2018)
- Leak: The “copyright troika” launches another censorship machine attack (02.05.2018)
- EU Council Presidency rushes to impose new copyfails in the EU (23.04.2018)
- New copyright compromise text: Filter or be filtered (07.03.2018)
- Final Copyright “compromise”: Upload filters for everyone but Google & Co (23.02.2018)
- Copyright reform: The Bulgarian Presidency strikes back (21.02.2018)
- Romania: Culture Ministry rallies copyright lobbyists (24.01.2018)
- Copyright reform: State of play (10.01.2018)
- Copyright Directive may lead newspapers to become their own censors (13.12.2017)
- School of Rock(ing) Copyright 2017: (Re-)united to #fixcopyright! (15.11.2017)
- New Estonian Presidency “compromise” creates copyright chaos (03.11.2017)
- Leak: Three EU countries join forces for restrictions & copyright chaos (26.10.2017)
- EU Council legal services unclear about censorship filters (17.10.2017)
- Civil society calls for the deletion of the #censorshipmachine (16.10.2017)
- Six states raise concerns about legality of Copyright Directive (05.09.2017)
- Copyright Directive discussed in Romania (26.07.2017)
- Copyfails: Time to #fixcopyright! (23.05.2017)
- Killing parody, killing memes, killing the internet? (08.05.2017)
- Copyright Directive: Lead MEP partly deletes the “censorship machine” (09.03.2017)
- A positive step forward against the “censorship machine” in the Copyright Directive (28.02.2017)
- Lead Parliamentarian for Culture Committee defends upload filtering (15.02.2017)
- EU Copyright Directive – privatised censorship and filtering of free speech (10.11.2016)
- The Copyright Reform – a guide for the perplexed (02.11.2016)
- Towards a corporate copyright reform in the EU? (31.08.2016)
Copyright Reform digest
- In the making: The largest internet filter Europe has ever seen (22.02.2018)
- European internet filter will destroy your freedom of expression: Stop it now! (27.02.2018)
- European policy makers want faulty filters to rule the internet: Your action is needed! (06.03.2018)
- Proposed internet filter will strip citizens of their rights: Your action is needed! (28.03.2018)
Other
- Frequently Asked Questions on copyright project by EUIPO.
- European Commission’s report on the public consultation (not published)
- Impact Assessment on the modernisation of EU copyright rules
- Eurobarometer report Internet users’ preferences for accessing content online and country factsheets
- Synopsis report on the Panorama exception
- Synopsis report on the ancillary copyright
- Synopsis reports in other languages and contributions to both consultations on the panorama exception and ancillary copyright.
- Event organised by EDRi and Communia on 8 September 2016 (summary and video).
- Letter from 30 academics to EU institutions
- A Brief Exegesis of the Proposed Copyright Directive paper prepared by Sophie Stalla-Bourdillon, Eleonora Rosati, Karmen Turk, Christina Angelopoulos, Aleksandra Kuczerawy, Miquel Peguera, Martin Husovec.
- Copyright Reform: Open Letter from European Research Centres (22.02.2017)
- On Online Platforms and the Commission’s New Proposal for a Directive on Copyright in the Digital Single Market (study by Dr Christina Angelopoulos, Centre for Intellectual Property and Information Law (CIPIL) University of Cambridge (January 2017)
- Open Letter by 70+ Internet Luminaries Ring the Alarm on EU Copyright Filtering Proposal (11 June 2018)
- Blog Post by Paul Sieminski from Automattic, the company that created WordPress: ‘We’re Against Bots, Filtering, and the EU’s New Copyright Directive’ (12 June 2018)
- Article by BBC News: ‘Copyright law could put an end to net memes’ (8 June 2018)
- Article by Marius François in Le Figaro: ‘Un projet de loi européen pourrait menacer les mèmes sur Internet’ (in French – 8 June 2018)
- Article by Glyn Moody in Arstechnica: ‘Illegal memes? Weak Safe Harbor? Unpacking the proposed EU copyright overhaul’ (12 June 2018)
- Article by Mike Masnick in Techdirt: ‘Ending The Memes: EU Copyright Directive Is No Laughing Matter’ (12 June 2018)
- Article by Pablo Romero in Publico: ‘Alerta: Europa puede cargarse la Wikipedia y los memes con sus normas sobre ‘copyright” (in Spanish – 12 June 2018)
- Article by Elsa Trujillo on BFMtv: ‘Pourquoi les mèmes sur Internet sont en danger’ (in French – 11 June 2018)
- Article by Jochen G. Fuchs on t3n news: ‘ Vergesst die DSGVO: Das Netz verliert gerade seine Informationsfreiheit’ (in German – 11 June 2018)
- Article by Sky News: ‘Memes ‘will be banned’ under new EU copyright law, warn campaigners’ (8 June 2018)
- Article by Mollie Cahillane in Daily Mail: ‘Could this be the end of memes? EU’s proposed rules on copyright could kill off user-generated content, critics warn’ (8 June 2018)
- Article by Futurezone Technology News: ‘Neues Urheberrecht könnte Aus für Memes bedeuten’ (in German – 8 June 2018)
- Article by Emanuel Karlsten in Göteborgs-Posten: ‘Karlsten: En av vår generations största politiska ödesfrågor’ (in Swedish – 8 June 2018)
- Article by Glyn Moody on BoingBoing: ‘ Of Dog’s Breakfasts, Article 13, and Mythbusting’ (7 June 2018)
- Article by Jonathan Greig on TechRepublic: ‘EU copyright reform proposal: 3 things businesses need to know’ (8 June 2018)
- Blog Post from Jan Gerlach of the Wikimedia Foundation on ‘Sacrificing freedom of expression and collaboration online to enforce copyright in Europe?’ (6 June 2018)
- Blog Post from Wikimedia France on ‘Réforme européenne du droit d’auteur : menaces sur les projets Wikimedia’ (in French – 11 June 2018)
- Blog Post by MEP Julia Reda (Germany, Greens/EFA, Shadow Rapporteur on the file) on How you can #SaveYourInternet from Article 13 and the “Link Tax” in the next 14 days (6 June 2018)
- Heise news article on the copyright reform (in German)
- Next Inpact news article on Article 13 (in French and partially behind a paywall)
- Torrentfreak article ‘Judgment Day Nears for EU’s ‘Piracy Filters’ by Ernesto Van der Sar (4 June 2018)
- Article by Thomas McMullan on Alphr: Article 13 could “destroy the internet as we know it”: What is it, why is it controversial and what will it mean for memes?
- Communia blog: Article 13 in 3 flowcharts
- Mozilla’s ChangeCopyright list of resources
- European Digital Rights EDRi’s copyright reform document pool
- Vox Scientia’s Censorship Machine 1-min, 10-min, 1-hour briefing pages
- Github’s blog post on the impact on code sharing
- EU Copyright Reform Information Page of the University RCUK Centre for Copyright and New Business Models in the Creative Economy (CREATe)
- Open Letter by Academics from 25 leading Intellectual Property research centres in Europe (24 May 2018)
- Study by Dr. Christina Angelopoulos On Online Platforms and the Commission’s New Proposal for a Directive on Copyright in the Digital Single Market (January 2017)
- Position Statement of the Max Planck Institute for Innovation and Competition on the Proposed Modernisation of European Copyright Rules. Part G – Use of Protected Content on Online Platforms
Key policy-makers
European Parliament Committees
- Lead Committee: Legal Affairs (JURI)
- Rapporteur: Axel Voss
- Shadow Rapporteurs:
- Lidia Joanna Geringer de Oedenberg
- Angel Dzhambazki
- Jean-Marie Cavada
- Jiří Maštálka
- Julia Reda
- Isabella Adinolfi
- Marie-Christine Boutonnet
- Lidia Joanna Geringer de Oedenberg
- Other Committees issuing Opinions:
- INTA– the Committee decided not to give an Opinion
- ITRE, Rapporteur: Zdzisław Krasnodębski
- IMCO, Rapporteur: Catherine Stihler
- CULT, Rapporteur: Marc Joulaud
- LIBE, Rapporteur: Michał Boni
Key dates*
- JURI
Lead Committee vote: 10.10.2017Update!: Vote schedule for 20-21 June 2018
- Update! Adoption of the result of the copyright trilogues: 26 February 2019
- Update! PLENARY FINAL VOTE (TBC): Scheduled for 15-18 April 2019
- Update! Vote in the Council of the result of the copyright trilogues: 20 February 2019